Setting Clear Expectations
Most performance problems begin with unclear expectations. When employees don't know what success looks like, they can't reliably achieve it. Clear expectations specify outcomes (what needs to be accomplished), standards (how well it needs to be done), and timelines (by when).
Write expectations down. Verbal expectations are subject to misremembering and misinterpretation. Written expectations create a shared reference point and make performance conversations more objective. Review them at the start of each year and update them when the role or business priorities change.
Feedback That Changes Behavior
Effective feedback is specific, timely, and focused on behavior rather than character. 'You missed the deadline on the Johnson proposal' is specific and behavioral. 'You're not reliable' is vague and characterological. The first gives the employee something to act on; the second just makes them defensive.
Give feedback close to the event. Feedback delivered weeks after the fact loses its impact and feels like score-keeping. Make it a habit to give brief, specific feedback — positive and corrective — in the normal flow of work rather than saving it for formal reviews.
Managing Underperformance
When an employee is underperforming, the first question is whether the problem is skill (they can't do it) or will (they won't do it). Skill problems require training, coaching, or role reassignment. Will problems require a different conversation about expectations, consequences, and fit.
Document performance issues as they occur. A performance improvement plan (PIP) should be a genuine attempt to help an employee succeed, not a paper trail for termination. Specify the performance gap, the required improvement, the support you'll provide, and the timeline. Follow through on both the support and the consequences.
Accountability Without Micromanagement
Accountability means people do what they say they'll do and own the outcomes of their work. Micromanagement means monitoring every step of how they do it. The first builds a high-performing team; the second destroys one.
Build accountability through clear expectations, regular check-ins on outcomes (not activities), and consistent follow-through on commitments — yours as well as theirs. When you make a commitment to your team and don't follow through, you signal that commitments are optional. Model the accountability you want to see.